食事

Sukiya vs. Yoshinoya Beef Sukiyaki Hot Pot Review: Is It Worth 950 Yen?

Sukiya Beef Sukiyaki Hot Pot promotional poster

Drawn by the Storefront Poster to Sukiya! Smooth Ordering via Touchscreen

I spotted a storefront poster for the seasonal "Gyusuki Nabe" (Beef Sukiyaki Hot Pot) signaling the arrival of winter, and found myself drawn right inside. Having recently tried Yoshinoya's Beef Sukiyaki Hot Pot set (read my previous review here), I couldn't help but wonder: "How does Sukiya's version compare?" and decided to check it out.

I took a seat at the counter and navigated the tabletop touchscreen tablet to find what I was looking for. This time, I ordered the standard "Beef Sukiyaki Hot Pot Set (1 Egg, Regular Rice)" for 950 yen including tax.

Ordering the Beef Sukiyaki Hot Pot set on Sukiya's touchscreen tablet

The "Beef Sukiyaki Hot Pot Set (Regular)" Arrives! High Visual Impact but Mixed Tasting Impressions

The time from ordering to delivery at the table was remarkably fast. Looking at the pot served right in front of me, the first thing that caught my eye was the towering pile of raw Chinese cabbage, green onions, and carrots. It was piled so high that the beef was practically hidden, offering a truly generous heap of vegetables.

Sukiya Beef Sukiyaki Hot Pot served with a generous mound of raw vegetables

However, as I started eating, what really stood out to me was the initial serving condition and the temperature. Yoshinoya preheats the pot in the kitchen to a certain degree before serving, so you can enjoy it piping hot right from the start. Sukiya, on the other hand, delivers it very quickly, but the ingredients arrive completely raw and cold.

You have to wait for the solid fuel burner on the table to heat everything up, and it took quite a while for the ingredients to cook through. To make matters worse, the flame burned out before the broth could come to a proper rolling simmer, leaving me to eat lukewarm food for the second half of the meal.

Perhaps as a result, the ingredients lacked that deeply simmered flavor where the broth thoroughly infuses every bite, and the portion of meat felt a bit overshadowed by the massive amount of veggies. While the classic sweet-and-savory soy sauce broth was flavorful enough, considering the price point of 950 yen—higher than Yoshinoya's 899 yen—the overall satisfaction fell somewhat short.

[Summary] Honest Advice When Choosing Between Sukiya and Yoshinoya

While the lightning-fast service from order to table is definitely attractive, when it comes to the essentials of a hot pot—piping hot temperature and deeply simmered umami—Yoshinoya clearly takes the win, largely thanks to its kitchen preparation process.

Store rush hours and individual solid fuel burners may cause variations, but if you have both chains nearby and can choose, my personal recommendation leans toward Yoshinoya. However, if your priority is packing in plenty of vegetables or minimizing wait time, Sukiya is still well worth considering.

-食事

© 2026 695TFのブログ Powered by AFFINGER5